Showing posts with label Best Films. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Best Films. Show all posts

Sunday, 21 December 2025

Review of 2025: Part 2 – Movies

Being the usual cycle through the year's cinematic shenanigans, handily divided into 26 'discoveries', 10 old favourites, seven new least-favourites, six re-appraisals and five obsessions. We began with the most important bit: the movies I saw for the first time and most enjoyed.

26 DISCOVERIES
1. Crossing Delancey (Joan Micklin Silver, 1988) – *SPOILERS* A Jewish Moonstruck, and somehow just as good – though here she loves the pleasant little guy, not the big and brooding one. The film seems to go awry in its third act, but don’t worry, writer Sandler and director Silver know exactly what they're doing; we had to go through that to get this. While the Roches will always be the ersatz McGarrigles, here they’re the perfect accompaniment, helping to cast a spell that rarely wavers and never fades, not even months later. This one moved me very deeply.

2. Rachel Getting Married (Jonathan Demme, 2008) – An astonishing film, its great balancing act underlined by how acerbically destructive Anne Hathaway’s Kym is, yet how seriously she treats AA and everyone there. Her monologue in a meeting takes what could be melodrama and does something with it that is never going to leave me. So much of the film hits close to home, and usually in that case it serves only to highlight how false the material rings, but, just once in a long while, it does the opposite. Rachel Getting Married is that exception. Guilt. Addiction. Family. Truth. Fuck.
3. Khane-ye doust kodjast? (Abbas Kiarostami, 1987) aka Where Is the Friend’s House? – A frowningly serious little Iranian boy tries to return his classmate’s workbook, and so save him from expulsion, in this extraordinary film. It’s a portal into another world, with a collision of elements that feels utterly novel: a thriller that radiates pure charm; Francois Truffaut’s After Hours; a wild goose chase pausing periodically to lament the passing of some old ways – the death of craftsmanship, old doors replaced by iron ones – and satirise the pointless irrelevance of others (our protagonist's grandfather tediously elaborating on the virtues of weekly beatings). There's witty circularity, mild absurdity and incomprehending pain here, but above all there is a faith in a conscientious form of humanism. Our culture tells us that children pester and nag and repeat things; Kiarostami’s radical viewpoint is that adults just aren’t listening. His film’s resourceful hero, then, takes matters into his own hands – and thank goodness. “Good work.”

4. Letyat zhuravli (Mikhail Kalatozov, 1957) aka The Cranes Are Flying – I’ve never seen anything quite like this. Who blocked and edited it, God?!
5. Si muero antes de despertar (Carlos Hugo Christensen, 1952) aka If I Should Die Before I Wake – A spectacular child’s-eye noir: like Where Is the Friend’s House if the hero were Argentine, the naughtiest boy in school, and hunting a serial killer. It’s tense, funny and deeply moving, full of vividly cinematic ideas, and with every scene seemingly better than the one before.

6. Glory (Edward Zwick, 1989) – What a writer Kevin Jarre was: his script for Glory is so nuanced in its characterisation, so unglamorous in its treatment of war and the grubbiness of duty, and so full of authentic and beautifully rendered dialogue. It was pointed out at the time, and has been regularly since, that he is a white writer focusing on a white colonel in this story of the Civil War's first Black regiment... but that is to puff up the reviewer's own progressive credentials at the expense of Jarre's achievement, and to do a disservice to the nature of the film, which draws (as the writer loved to do) from the best historical sources (in this case, the real-life letters of that white colonel), while allowing us to sit, repeatedly, with those Black soldiers. Yes, it asks us to sympathise with the wet-eyed guilt that the commanding officer feels at publicly flogging a Black guy, but it allows us also to understand the forces pressing down upon both men. The insights that we get from the letters themselves are small moments of revelation: not least the immediacy with which the Black soldiers could switch from drilling mode to their freer selves. Just now and then, director Zwick and a syrupy, overly conventional James Horner score take the film to somewhere less specific, yet that score comes into its own during the stunning climactic sequence, and it's Jarre himself, as a writer and actor, who gives us the most obviously Hollywood moment: the cry of "Give 'em hell, 54th!" that feels historically real, emotionally real and as calculated as something from a 1940s weepie. It is the most simply and deeply moving line in a picture that's hardly short of them. The cast, too, is superb: Freeman the veteran freeman, Braugher the bespectacled intellectual, and Denzel (in his breakthrough role) disfigured by repressed rage. His introductory scene is a masterpiece that turns on a dime, showing the unifying power of humour, and of a shared frame of reference. If Matthew Broderick is only competent as the colonel, his slight callowness as an actor proves a happy accident that fits the part.
7. The Ballad of Wallis Island (James Griffiths, 2025) – Carey + folk music + the familiar rhythms and vernacular of Tim Key + an understanding of grief + a cricket scene, and all on an island. Perhaps personal, customisable films are already here? (Yet such flawed and human beauty is the very antithesis of AI.) It’s Inside Llewyn Davis with a flame in its heart, Seducing Doctor Lewis in the acoustic idiom, and while it’s slightly schematic in shape, it deviates from expectation in just the right ways. It’s deeply moving, very funny and so beautifully acted, while feeling about music the same way that I do. I really loved it.

8. Just Pals (John Ford, 1920) – “The boobs will all be at prayer meetin’, and it’s goin’ to be an easy job.” A stunning film: one of the Master’s greatest extant silents. The story is simple melodrama – featuring both an orphan, and a villain who steals the school memorial fund – but oh what Ford does with it. Even in 1920, he’s siding with the outsider against small-town hypocrisy: as in his immortal Stagecoach, the most heinous character on screen is a respected banker. Since the pals of the title are local layabout Buck Jones and a little urchin (who turns out to be goodhearted and yet fantastically untamable and rude), there are obvious parallels with Chaplin’s The Kid, which came out the next year, but this one is more bucolic and, critically and above all, about the quality of mercy. There are so many wonderful small moments here – what Ford called his ‘grace notes’ – a cascade of petals, a lens-flooding sunset, a sackful of kittens getting a last-second reprieve. No-one but Ford would have turned to those details, or rendered them with such unapologetic sincerity. This was the director’s first film at Fox, and his new lead, Buck Jones, proves himself as real star material (though at one point he does the signature arm-grab of the director’s usual muse, Harry Carey?!). The love interest, incidentally, is Helen Ferguson, later a powerful Hollywood PR for actors like Stanwyck. During those hazy, lazy shots of Jones in his element, Ford uses the hay loft as a portrait frame within the landscape one, placing the hero with his back to us, a shot that I can’t remember any other director ever using, creating a portal into a contrasting world, as at the end of The Searchers.
9. Gimme Shelter (Albert Maysles, David Maysles and Charlotte Zwerin, 1970) – Most gig films don’t have a body count. But this ominous doc chronicles the nightmare of Altamont, as the Stones announce a free show staffed by Hell’s Angels, and events spiral rapidly and inexorably out of control. While you’ll know the story – and its place in a neat and tidy 20th century narrative – seeing it is something else: the nightmarish trips, a testiness that flares into beatings, and the chilling feeling that if it carries on like this, someone is going to get killed. The film is brilliantly framed, with Jagger and Watts reviewing footage in the studio, and a wrap-around narrative about the impending tragedy, which is then held back as we’re escorted on the rest of the band’s North American tour. The Stones are a weird band, for sure – freshfaced Londoners playing at the blues – and what might have been incredible in the room isn’t always as convincing on screen (Jagger sacrificing his vocals for movement, then waddling like a duck). What the Maysles realised, though, is that this is only tangentially a movie about music; it is instead a snapshot of a movement that, if minor in itself, took on an outsized and emblematic significance – in part, of course, due to their film. There are small on-stage pleasures – Tina Turner’s paintstripping soul, Jagger shouting “Well alright!” like Neil Kinnock – but everything is weighted towards, and coloured by, what is coming. So yes, Gram Parsons sings ‘Six Days on the Road’, but it’s his pleading with the audience not to hurt each other that will live in the memory. The worst gig of all time, then. With George Lucas behind one camera, and Walter Murch recording sound.

10. Sanshô dayû (Kenji Mizoguchi, 1954) aka Sansho the Bailiff – Last year I found myself watching Bird on a Wire, the much-maligned caper comedy starring Mel Gibson and Goldie Hawn, and made a joke about how I was watching this shite but still hadn’t seen Sansho the Bailiff. There was a truth underlying it, though: I’d been skimping on international cinema for a little while: largely reading when I felt able to intellectually engage, then watching comfort movies and genre films when I didn’t. I couldn’t see Sansho as a teenager because like all classics of world cinema, the VHS was £17.49 in HMV, but I haven’t had that excuse for a while. So it felt great to finally commit, in this new year, to watching probably the best-known and most celebrated movie I’d never seen, and one that at least from the outside seemed challenging and demanding. Of course, once you’re into it, you remember that those distinctions are false: if a movie grips, it grips. As obvious and slightly snobbish as the comparison may be, though, the difference that I felt in watching this, compared to a mediocre John Badham movie, was broadly analogous to that between eating junk food and something that’s good for you. I’m keen to try to do both. Because this Japanese folk tale about suffering, slavery and redemption was truly glorious: painterly, emotionally complicated, and periodically profound.
11. Hester Street (Joan Micklin Silver, 1975) – Silver's arresting debut: a flavourful film about Jews on the Lower East Side in the 1890s, which like several of her later movies pretends to be about the emotional travails of an unremarkable and self-centred man, but is actually about the woman he's trying to trample beneath his feet. She's Gitl (Carol Kane), who arrives at Ellis Island as an embarrassing reminder of his Eastern European past (no English, no apparent guile, an aversion to ever displaying her real hair) but isn't, much to his and our surprise, anybody's meek and martyred wife. The movie isn't flawless in the details of its filming or performance, but it's close to perfect in the sweep of the thing. And it has a lot to say not just on gender relations, but about the nature of cultural assimilation. Kane is the stand-out here, of course, but Dorrie Kavanaugh has an agreeably showy bit as her theoretical love rival, a Polish immigrant who speaks like Dietrich.

12. Rolling Thunder (John Flynn, 1977) – *SPOILERS* “Why do I always get stuck with crazy men?” “‘Cause that’s the only kind that’s left” A scintillating early Schrader script (rewritten by Heywood Gould) about a damaged Vietnam vet who winds up cleaning out a rats’ nest. Heard that one before? William Devane is the returning POW who, on the outside, is an all-American hero, and on the inside... well, there is no inside anymore. One remarkable thing about cinema is how poorly its worthy prestige pictures tend to age, and yet how much vitality, honesty and life there is to the genre trash that was largely derided upon release, but perhaps appealed to people’s truer instincts, and tells us so much more about the times. This one is astonishing, really, particularly in that near-perfect first half, which confounds you at every turn, while staying utterly true to a startlingly realised central character who, himself, seems utterly true. (Perhaps only those flashbacks – looking a little cheap, playing a little trite – land wide of the mark.) The remainder of the picture, a road trip en route to a bloodbath, has the odd misstep or slow stretch but also moments you’ll never forget, ending with Tommy Lee Jones blasting bad guys in a whorehouse, and an overt nod to The Searchers (an enduring influence on Schrader), in which he is Natalie Wood. (Jones's immortal line, "I'll just get my gear", manages to be quietly horrifying, deeply moving and just about the peak of bro cinema.) The varied score is way above average too, with one Tex-Mex theme that seems to anticipate Paris, Texas. A minor classic, in its periodically confounding, quasi-fascist Nixonian way.
13. The Browning Version (Anthony Asquith, 1951) – A scintillating Rattigan adaptation, filmed mostly in Asquith’s invisible late style, with Redgrave in incomparable form as a pedantic, apparently bloodless classics teacher hiding vast private torments. It’s an extremely English tragedy – a sort of Mr Chips for the melancholy – though containing the writer’s usual chink of light, in his usual counter-intuitive style. The character of Redgrave’s shrewish, adulterous wife (played by Jean Kent) appears for a while to be alarmingly one-note, but it isn’t quite that: it is instead the result of an ascetic marrying a sensualist, and not even realising at first that he had done so.

14. The Truman Show (Peter Weir, 1998) – I'd somehow seen half of this a couple of times, but I don't think I'd ever seen the whole thing. Beyond everything else, it's a truly great love story, done essentially in two scenes and two moments. The date sequence with McElhone, which begins in the library and ends on the beach, is so beautifully written, directed and played. And the film is daring in structure and form, timely and fairly prescient on reality TV and celebrity culture (check the complicity of the small screen audience, who cheer him on while keeping him in bondage), and quietly profound about escapism through media, the fetishisation of small-town values, and – most importantly – life itself. There's one particularly nice satirical moment in which Truman realises his entire life might be a sham, and all we can really focus on is the Ford logo on his car. My only complaint: Carrey’s performance feels too tied to its twin poles of fleeting, self-serious sincerity and his usual cartoonish shtick, though the final scene ties the two together with such panache that you wonder if that was always intentional.
15. Dream Lover (Nicholas Kazan, 1994) – *SPOILERS* Very much my sort of thing: a demonic-woman noir, with the most beautiful screen couple since Delon and Cardinale in The Leopard. It's from 1993, when everyone was fucking and you did business deals with the Japanese. James Spader plays a divorced architect who spills wine all over damaged, free-spirited Lena (Mädchen Amick), meets her again in a supermarket, spies on her (a bit), sleeps with her, marries her, and starts a family. Hurray: a half-hour movie with a happy ending! Oh wait. Someone is calling her Sissy and saying she's from Texas. Her parents don’t actually appear to be dead. Her friend Debby from dance class might not exist. And what are all these Visa charges for the Hotel Chantecler? I found this movie so deliriously entertaining. It's padded here and there (the carnival inserts, a home video sequence), it's tasteless and even immoral in its treatment of mental illness and domestic violence, and it has a strange last act culminating in a reshot ending that I don't think quite works. It is also regularly pilloried for being misogynistic, and while I'd argue that it's primarily absolved through being a fairly obvious and extremely vivid genre exercise, there really isn't any reason for Spader to punch his wife in the face, with the film's full blessing, and it arguably undermines both central characters, and the plot, to have him do so. However, for over an hour this is plotted like a Highsmith novel, and has one of the great fatales, who offers a sight we thought we'd never seen on screen, the beautiful Spader, with his fey delivery and those funny winces, being not just run rings around, but somehow out-prettied. I'm sorry if it's toxic to say so, but I would probably just give Lena a pass on all this stuff she's up to, she's gorgeous. It’s also fascinating how writer-director Kazan, son of all-time great filmmaker and ratfink, Elia, leans more on Pandora's Box here than he does on Double Indemnity or Leave Her to Heaven. Distracting point for any snooker fans: Spader’s character is called Ray Reardon.

16. The Holdovers (Alexander Payne, 2023) – *SOME SPOILERS* Nice: they fixed Dead Poets Society (kind of like how John Hughes fixed Pretty in Pink with Some Kind of Wonderful). At the moment of truth, Payne knows that selling out your fellow man is about the worst thing one can do, and there is always an alternative – though perhaps standing up is easier for an adult. The film is similar to Tom McCarthy’s Win-Win, and indeed to most of Payne’s mid-period movies, but it’s a lovely same, in its familiar, 2011-ish way. He doesn’t push too far, or expect his characters to transform themselves: a partial unfurling, sufficient to connect again, is enough. Then it's down to what was always there. When 'The Wind' by Cat Stevens kicks in, early in the second half, you feel that the song is making you feel in a way that the story hasn’t quite, save perhaps for during that Christmas dinner. But, by the end, the film has you.
17. Sinners (Ryan Coogler, 2025) – *A FEW SPOILERS* It’s all about the time-slip, isn’t it: the walls between past, present and future dissolving in a carousel of Black (and East Asian) culture, the camera swinging drunkenly, as energised as the people around it, and Coolger filling your ears with the devilish ecstasy of the blues, as he fills the screen with 1930s partygoers, hip hop dancers and a flying V. It’s particularly impressive as a feat of daring, since like so many great gambles it risks being silly, but is instead enough to give you a faint sense of hope for the state of mainstream cinema, added Rick melodramatically. I suppose this one just does the From Dusk Till Dawn trick, and yet doing so with a race relations drama isn’t the exercise in Biden-era handwringing you might fear. It’s a masterstroke. Because that supercharges the very vampire genre with race, rendering tempting the sense of belonging, while threatening the destruction of authentic Black culture through both intra-community moralising and excessive assimilation. Simply: if you give up your identity as a Black man, you lose your soul. No matter what the list of Best Picture winners tells you, genre films have always been the best medium for any message you might want to send. We don't want a pompous lecture, we want to have fun. And Sinners is FUN. It is also, at the most instant level, a battle between the blues and folk, though the former is depicted in its most exhilarating form, while the latter is bowdlerised into a joke. It’s a funny joke, though. While it might have been more authentic for the Klanpires to have been rooted in authentic southern folk music, it is hilarious (and close to exhilarating?) that they swing their banjos in unison, love ‘Blooming Heather’ and do an Irish jig to ‘The Rocky Road to Dublin’. The music is mostly stunning: the set-pieces possessing a similar energy and semi-factual feel to the ones in Luhrmann’s excellent Elvis biopic. Perhaps the best is Little Sammy’s blues song in the car, the entrepreneur’s jaw dropping at what he’s hearing, or perhaps just the money there is to be made. Hell he can play. Despite the obvious differences, Goransson’s ominous, pulsing synths seem to belong to the same world. Maybe Sinners didn’t need its five endings. The wish-fulfilment of the Blaxploitation-ish Klan shoot-out is understandable, but is also the part that doesn’t quite fit. A Fresh Prince-ish coda with Buddy Guy trades danger for quirky mawk, veering close to a cop-out. Sinners is a great time, though. It’s full of life and joy and imagination, with scarcely a piece of IP in sight (do the rules of vampirism count?), favouring instead sequences of taut, Tarantino-ish tension – in the negotiation of a juke joint purchase, in a doorman wanting to be let back into the building – vivid character sketches and quite a lot of chat about cunnilingus. An extra half a star for Miles Caton’s highly pleasing speaking voice.

18. A Real Pain (Jesse Eisenberg, 2024) – I felt a little queasy, and uneasy, about a Holocaust tour being used as the backdrop for a comedy-drama about a contemporary familial relationship; then I realised that Eisenberg is doing something remarkable here: not just combating generational trauma through the familiar defence of nebbish humour, and questioning the validity of modern pain in the shadow of unimaginable horrors, but purposefully reasserting a Jewish individuality, in its inevitably complicated and thorny nature, that is the antithesis of the Shoah. His film reminded me a little of The Darjeeling Limited, though with a much more coherent emotional background, and of Philomena, which offset the sins of the past with the same sort of shimmering wit. Though A Real Pain is apparently unambitious in its scale: a small cast, a small-ish canvas, its achievements are outsized. That extends to the photography. There's something about the visual framing of the Ghetto Heroes memorial at the start of the tour that took my breath away: its incongruousness in any setting, the idea that this should have happened anywhere at all, let alone where we're standing. Culkin's character, Benji, is showstopping, and he's very good in the role, but it does occasionally tip towards cliché (and I have the obvious reservations about a non-Jewish actor in the part). Where he really works is in keeping you on edge, and in the small moments: particularly that devastating intake of breath when he sees the shoes at the camp. Eisenberg's role is less showy, but he's even better, I think. His short speech about pain is a remarkable feat of writing and performance, but is there anything better than the moment of reconnection before the coming ordeal, which is nothing more than two men saying "Hey" to one another. The biggest laugh in the picture is probably the tour-guide, David, trying to share his facts about the oldest headstone in Poland while adhering to Benji's oppressive and almost arbitrary limitations, though I also loved that sequence at the grandmother's old house. Surely the only thing more Jewish than the ritual of leaving stones on her old doorstep is what happens next.
19. Obsession (Edward Dmytryk, 1949) – A superb thriller about cuckold Robert Newton embarking on an elaborate, extended scheme to murder his usurper. Newton is terrific, playing upper-middle far better than he ever did working-class, and sparring memorably with Naunton Wayne, as the polite, supposedly oblivious but in fact omniscient detective (an archetype pioneered by Alastair Sim in Green for Danger?). There’s a recurring theme in the film about visiting Americans being given precedence over Brits, which is fun, as this was directed by blacklisted US filmmaker Edward Dmytryk, prior to his 1950 jail-term; his artisanal skill augments every scene, right up until that embarrassing tacked-on ending.

20. Los Angeles Plays Itself (Thom Andersen, 2003) – This left-wing polemic about Los Angeles on film is highly entertaining and valuable if you’re a film location nerd, interested in the movie colony and the city that surrounds it, or just want to understand 20th century America. At its best, it calls to mind Caro’s ‘The Power Broker’, and I have no higher praise than that. The passages dealing with Los Angeles’ (never 'LA’s', we are cautioned) forgotten public history, and its phony ‘secret history’, are just dazzling, and there’s a great sincerity to Andersen’s bristling anger at the erasure of working class lives, both in mainstream film and from the razed community of Bunker Hill. But while this video essay is intellectually stimulating, provocative, pedantic in an anal way that I really don’t mind, and even waspishly funny, it is also overly grouchy. Our host knows an awful lot about movies, but he really doesn’t seem to like any of them (the sole exceptions, across almost three hours, are The Exiles, the original Gone in 60 Seconds, two porn films, and the calling cards of the tiresome, The Long Goodbye and the films of John Cassavetes). I would simply devote my life to something I enjoyed. I would also like to explain to him that all cities are misrepresented on screen – racially, culturally, geographically – and that Notting Hill was not neorealism, but then perhaps Los Angeles here is a prism through which we are meant to see the wider crimes of mass culture, and not a special case. There’s some of the inevitable pretension of the form, too, which seems to bring out an academic’s nascent egomania. Andersen throws in some truly puzzling contentions: the first teenagers with cars were in Rebel without a Cause (surely only true if you’re employing the fun argument that Ray invented the teenager); that some stag film is a "gay porn masterpiece"; and that “the greatest ‘low tourist’ director is, of course, Alfred Hitchcock”. Oh, of course. It's pretty great, though. It made me look at these movies in such a different way, from Hal Roach to Double Indemnity to Blade Runner, and who doesn’t want that.
21. Neotpravlennoye pismo (Mikhail Kalatozov, 1960) aka Letter Never Sent – Before Fitzcarraldo, before even Aguirre, but some time after Way Down East, there was Letter Never Sent, a hard-won picture about man vs nature (and fate), in which four Russian geological explorers try to get the hell out of the variously burning, flooding and snow-bound Siberian wilds with their discoveries – and their lives – intact. At its best, simply stunning, with astonishing location footage, Kalatozov’s jawdropping visual flourishes, and plotting that is both ineluctable and impossible to second guess. It is also admittedly a little uneven – at times plodding, almost by definition – but has explosions of unexpected joy, for which you, and these characters, really have to suffer.

22. The Gallant Hours (Robert Montgomery, 1960) – A reverential but riveting, unsentimental drama about the lead-up to the battle of Guadalcanal, largely following around Admiral ‘Bull’ Halsey (Cagney). The star is brilliant, obviously, and there’s one counter-intuitive scene between Halsey and a young flyer who wants to be relieved of command that is particularly special, explicitly disavowing speechmaking, and then offering something more profound.
23. The Shopworn Angel (H. C. Potter, 1938) – Margaret Sullavan is absolutely beguiling as a stroppy, hedonistic stage diva shaken to her senses by a guileless Texan soldier (Jimmy Stewart, so aww-shucks innocent he's almost simple). It isn't a straightforward love story, though – in fact, I might have liked it even more if it were – but an intriguing if not entirely successful melodrama in which he teaches her how to love, and she falls for a vaguely debauched Broadway financier (Walter Pidgeon), while feeling she owes the smitten doughboy a marriage before he ships off to France. The early courtship scenes between Sullavan and Stewart are something like the apogee of Hollywood romance, which makes the remainder slightly unsatisfying – and hard to parse, emotionally – though it still has magical moments. Waldo Salt's excellent dialogue helps. The idiotic dubbing of Maggie's singing doesn't, and undercuts the effectiveness of the critical final scene.

24. Unfinished Business (Gregory La Cava, 1941) – This is so nearly a great film, and certainly one with dazzling passages of modernity and maturity, as Irene Dunne – fleeing the fate of a spinster – takes a train out of her small town, and, on that train, fucks the first guy she meets (Preston Foster). She thinks he’s sincere, he’s anything but, and yet this is no creaking melodrama but a picture that’s touching, often incredibly funny, and, at its best, genuinely profound. In its greatest, far later scene, Dunne and her estranged husband (Robert Montgomery, playing Foster’s brother) sit on the stairs in her boarding house, and she explains the tenets of female desire that give the film its title. Even if the film ultimately backs away, terrified, from the conclusions it has unearthed there, that sequence remains a masterpiece of counter-intuition and complexity, and still looks at least 30 years ahead of its time. There are numerous special moments, though: a song at a piano, and the softening it engenders; by far Walter Catlett’s funniest work on screen (as a thinly-veiled Billy Rose); and Eugene Pallette’s performance as a squeaky-shoed butler, which mirrors the trajectory of the film in seguing from comedy to something far more affecting. There is, occasionally, something of Remember the Night about this film, and that’s not just the highest praise I can offer, but about the rarest. And there is too, a moment of erotic expression that drew an astonished gasp from an audience in 2025, followed hot on its heels by a fantastic moment of revelation, and then an inspired Mamoulian-ish flourish from La Cava, who pans up and down and across to find a succession of faces, each one afforded a snatch of gossip as it spreads like fire though a room. Such startling invention, though, and such daring, is at times undermined by moments of contrived characterisation, and some terrible plotting. The film first stutters when indulging in one of those drunk scenes that La Cava (a self-deluding alcoholic – is there any other kind?) thought so amusing and important to story construction, yet has there ever been a funny drunk scene? For a film with as many laughs as this one (and no light opera virtuoso was ever half as good at comedy as Dunne), it’s also strange that it requires such frequent recourse to jokes about people being fat and ugly. And there’s no question that the director’s vaunted improvisational approach is a double-edged sword, leading to some fascinating dynamics and fabulously unresolved scene endings, but also some extremely uneven – and even unconvincing – sequences. I wanted to love Unfinished Business unreservedly, and for a half hour I did, revelling in its balance of elements, and at the rare sound of a Code-era woman exhaling with horniness, as Foster puts the moves on Dunne. If, once the leads start drinking, the film becomes conspicuously inconsistent, its most extraordinary moments are nevertheless housed in that erratic remainder.
25. Acting on Impulse (Sam Irvin, 1993) – If an erotic thriller has at least two alternate titles, you know it’s going to make no apologies for itself. This one has three, being known variously as Eyes of a Stranger, Secret Lives, and Roses Are Dead. Fiorentino is just fantastic in it, warming up for The Last Seduction, playing a presumed murderess now wreaking sexual and emotional havoc at a hotel where a convention is on. She remains an utterly beguiling screen presence, quite unlike anything before or since. The film around her is imperfect but highly likeable: a spin on Bad Influence, but with the atmosphere of Something Wild, tons of horniness, and a cast that includes Nancy Allen, Isaac Hayes, Charles Lane, Dick Sargent, Zelda Rubinstein and Adam Ant! The meta stuff that it leads with barely works, the comedy is broad where it should be blackly funny, and the climactic reveal is dubious to say the least, but who among us doesn’t want a peak-era Fiorentino to come save/ruin our life? As in Bad Influence, we are presented with a corporate wimp (C. Thomas Howell) who is handed a backbone by a dark stranger, but this film is – deceptively – a far sweeter proposition. I enjoyed its scuzzy unpredictability, the fun score, and some unusual, very long and apparently improvised sex scenes. The direction is variable: there’s that lovely image of a departing motorbike reflected in a sports car, and the production detail of the bottom of Fiorentino’s sports socks being grey-black after a day of slobbing around the flat is impeccable, but I was less impressed by the single most cliched down-the-staircase shot I have ever seen. The sequence in a cowtown bar may as well be taking place 10 yards from the one in The Last Seduction, though it would take a little time, the star’s assertiveness and two noir obsessives to land on Fiorentino’s perfect persona. Yes there is a makeover scene in which Allen gets off with both male and female lead.

26. Maman Calibri (Julien Duvivier, 1929) aka Mother Hummingbird – Why Are Men?: The Movie. The first 45 minutes of this one, climaxing with a kiss, are intoxicating, closer to Lubitsch’s Student Prince than Fannie Hurst. The rest is rather too drawn-out, beginning with finger-pointing melodrama and ending with mawkishness, though it still has great moments growing out of the showy direction and incredible Algerian location photography. Hollywood films in 1930 couldn’t have SKIES like these. There’s also one notably excellent little scene in front of a mirror that predates The Substance by 90-plus years, and ends with a moment of magnificent and horrible awkwardness, all the better for being so low-key. Its story is something like The Graduate from Mrs Robinson’s point of view, and so hews close to tragedy. Maria Jacobini is the socialite housewife who tires of her repressive family life and begins an affair with her older son’s friend (Francis Lederer, in his slightly goofy ‘Franz’ days). She goes with him to Algeria, where he proceeds to fall in love with a woman his own age (Hélène Hallier). “He is charming,” Hallier tells Jacobini as Lederer rides past, “is he your son?” I’m not so sure about the moment in the same scene where the heroine saves her future love rival from a bunch of African children by chucking one coin into the dirt, though I think Duvivier just wanted the automatic montage of faces and fabrics. I imagine those elements will fade from my memory fairly quickly, as the carousel of movement (and delayed gratification) in the ball sequence continues to waltz around my brain.

***

10 OLD FAVOURITES
1. The Student Prince in Old Heidelberg (Ernst Lubitsch, 1927) – Yes, I would like my heart broken into a million fucking pieces again, please. This is my favourite silent, and I had it in my Sight & Sound ballot, even though I’d only ever seen it on a decrepit NTSC VHS from the ‘80s. What a joy, then, to watch it on the big screen, on film, with the Carl Davis score, with an in-person Kevin Brownlow introduction (!), and with an audience. Every choice Lubitsch makes is the right one, but how dearly I love the visual fluidity of Kathi’s first scene with the students. The first half of the film is just fantastically funny – Jean Hersholt, in his greatest performance, watching that final exam! – before the tragedy kicks in. The lesson, though, isn’t quite “never go back”; once reality punctures the idyll, perhaps returning just once more, only for a moment, is how you rescue what is left of the rest of your life.

2. The Searchers (John Ford, 1956) – I watched this for the millionth time, but this time in the new Warner Bros restoration, which looks incredible, so well done everyone. I wrote 4,000 words on this movie in my youth, I've since gone the other way, trying to pare down its magnificence to just a couple of pars. This time, a few stray thoughts:
- The way Ford shoots Wayne here: I've never seen anything like it. Mythmaking on the most gigantic scale: Ethan on a rearing horse, shot from below, enormous before the sprawling vista. Then those two horrifying later close-ups.
- I really think Ebert missed or misunderstood the point of the second storyline: "This second strand is without interest, and those who value The Searchers filter it out, patiently waiting for a return to the main story line," he says a little presumptuously. But it has at least four purposes: to counterpoint Ethan's loneliness, to paint an alternate history of the burned homestead, to offer societal context and a broader palette of emotions, and to provide that astonishing moment of whiplash near the close, when we realise that Ethan isn't some deranged outlier: the sweet, fun, feisty frontier girl thinks and feels the self-same thing that he does, he's just the man of action carrying out the job.
- Only Ford would cut from the most overwhelming moment of redemption ever realised on film to a shot of Ward Bond having a bullet removed from his arse.
- Frank Nugent's script can get overlooked by critics amid the rust-coloured soil and the groping towards a reckoning on race, but it has everything: terse poetry in the dialogue, a fondness for allusion that gifts you a dozen brooding, action-packed prequels, and a playfulness with the form that climaxes with that letter set-piece. Even the few elements I could live without, like the comedy 'squaw' sequence, do pay off, usually in the most subversive way; making her final actions unknown and unknowable is an unusually literary flourish that gives the film such a richness. Going through Letterboxd now, blocking every 21-year-old who has posted, "this movie is way racist??"
3. A Canterbury Tale (Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger, 1944) – The Glue Man is at it again. His singular MO? Finding women who are out late and pouring glue in their hair. Enter three amateur detectives: a Tommy, a Yank and the Land Girl who just became the 11th victim. Yet which other rotters commit their crimes to protect the marriages of absent soldiers, increase attendance at educational lectures, and facilitate God’s present-day miracles? The Archers’ tale of wartime pilgrims is languorous, magical and fantastically strange, alive with the ghosts and games of the Garden of England, and illuminated by a unique imagination. The “halo” at the train station may be the most exciting five seconds in British film. And remember, if you get caught pouring glue on someone, you were “pouring knowledge into people’s heads … knowledge of our country and love of its beauty.” This review appeared in Little White Lies.

4. One Way Passage (Tay Garnett, 1932) – I always like to rewatch an all-time favourite on my birthday. Assorted virtues:
- Luminescent photography (seen like never before on the gorgeous Warner Archive Blu-ray): a film in which every shot is beautiful, but the travelling shots especially.
- The greatest ever second-leads in a movie. Frank McHugh doing his patented ‘one-two-three’ laugh – usually rationed to once per film – in virtually every scene. Aline MacMahon rat-a-tat-ing in Brooklynese. And yet the best scene in the picture is that masterpiece in which this ostensibly comic pair, essentially just doling out exposition, aided by brilliantly economical, flavourful dialogue, invest an eternity of emotion and beauty in their relationship with Bill Powell, a murderer about to be hanged.
- Francis’s softness.
- Powell raising a hand in farewell, then raising both hands with a gun in his back.
- Warren Hymer, cinema’s archetypal dumb, gurning crim, for once getting to be cool.
- The studio era's understanding that you don't need to bother going on location, you just need a song that sounds a lot like it comes from the country in question.
- That ending.
5. The Grapes of Wrath (John Ford, 1940) – “We crackin’ up, Tom. They ain’t no family now.” An astonishingly effective version of Steinbeck’s masterpiece: a little different to the text, a touch less daring thematically, and perhaps in technique, but still extraordinary on its own terms, and by far the most radical film of its period. Critics have complained that sometimes the cruelty is softened or snipped out, or the financial sector’s responsibility muddied, but I don’t really buy it. The film remains pretty much unflinching, and the lack of someone that Muley and the rest “can shoot” to resolve the situation only serves to accentuate the living nightmare facing them. While the story is reordered to end with the government camp (Grant Mitchell, as the manager, even looks like FDR), it’s only Ma’s rather trite triumphal peroration in the closing seconds that strikes the wrong note. Between the imposition of the Code in mid-1934 and the work of Abraham Polonsky in 1947-8, and ignoring a couple of pro-Soviet films made at the request of the government, there were arguably three truly radical Hollywood movies: Holiday (a rom-com written by a communist), The Little Foxes (a Southern gothic melodrama written by a communist), and this one; The Grapes of Wrath is easily the most confrontational of the three. The cops lie, a sheriff red-baits, the banks foreclose, the script refuses to say if commies is [sic] good or bad, and a radical is forged: ex-con Tom Joad, who delivers the socialist speech to end them all, which is somehow smuggled into cinemas because the book had sold millions, the Popular Front still held, and it was just a country boy talking to his maw. “I’ll be all around in the dark,” he says, still sporting the scar from when he killed that lawman. “I’ll be everywhere. Wherever you can look – wherever there’s a fight, so hungry people can eat, I’ll be there. Wherever there’s a cop beatin’ up a guy, I’ll be there." Read on, here.

6. The Shop Around the Corner (Ernst Lubitsch, 1940) – This just looked close to perfect this time. Lubitsch’s delicate handling of the most sensitive subjects, using the grammar of his door gags at the darkest moment. His transparent love of Felix Bressart, a fellow Jewish German émigré possessed of vast warmth and exquisite comic timing. Peggy Sullavan entering the film and immediately saying “Yiss” at least three times, in that strange and wondrous voice of hers. That close-up of her through the PO box. The film’s disgust at yes-men. And an ending that always rather confounds me, eschewing simple sentiment in favour of something almost cruel, before letting the floodgates open; I think what Lubitsch is trying to do there is something truly ambitious and unusual, in placing the fickle mystery of in-person chemistry on a par with the reality of our deepest selves: no more but certainly no less.
7. How Green Was My Valley (John Ford, 1941) – Life hack: convince people you’re Welsh by talking in an Irish accent and then saying “is it?” at the end. An exquisite Ford film, originally set to be a four-hour colour production in Wales – developed by William Wyler and screenwriter Philip Dunne – but ultimately shot in black-and-white in Malibu, and running under two hours. It’s sort of a test for how you feel about art, and what you prize within it, being utterly false in almost every literal detail, and utterly true in every emotion. At its best (and it remains the best thing Dunne ever did, with all of his virtues and few of his flaws), it is perhaps the greatest film ever made about childhood, and about memory, blessed with a remarkable sensitivity, and treating its young protagonist, Huw, with great sympathy and sincerity. He’s played by Roddy McDowall, who lights up the film with a miraculous performance – for me, still the standard by which all child actors might be judged. There are the familiar Ford touches too, the rhythm and the ritual, the beautiful work drawn from O’Hara (as Angharad) and the great Anna Lee (Bronwen). The first half is certainly disjointed, with some turgid dialogue scenes, Allgood and Crisp playing it too broad, and union stuff that barely works, but once O’Hara, Walter Pidgeon and McDowall are centre stage, it’s irresistible. There are eight or nine moments in the film that are simply extraordinary: Huw in the pew; Pidgeon breathing, “Angharad”; the brothers departing, unseen except by the camera… So much of the film’s great power comes from stoic, inky figures in the distance; Zanuck clearly cuts the departures to the bone, but still they haunt you. People will tell you that Kane is superior in every way, while lauding ‘innovations’ that Welles cribbed from Stagecoach and are continued here... But what if they’re both great? It is criminal that the UK version, with Rhys Williams doing the opening narration (as originally intended) isn’t more widely available.

8. Double Indemnity (Billy Wilder, 1944) – "I wonder if I know what you mean." "I wonder if you wonder." Watched for the dozenth time, I guess. It was a weirdly hard film to see in the '90s, but I've made up for that since. I still get a buzz from being able to do so. Every line is remarkable – or at least aims to be. It has the best names around, riffed on endlessly ever since: Walter Neff! Phyllis Dietrichson! Barton Keyes! And it has three unforgettable performance, which reveal a little more each time you see them. Wilder uses Stanwyck so sparingly, which is so smart. This isn't her best turn, but it's perhaps her last great one (there was still My Reputation, the Fuller, and the Sirks, but they can't dream of touching what came before). Man, the ugliness of her mouth in the reveal, but also the way she disarms Walter, and us, with those flashes of familiar sincerity, all false except (or including?) the last. One thing I've always loved about Wilder, and that often gets missed, is his instinctive need to swing towards humanism; he does it back-to-back here, at the end of his sourest film, and it is, in the modern parlance, a hell of a swing. Murray's smug, fatalistic white-collar shithell is a joy too. The leads are, except when cannily weaponising their screen baggage, completely unrecognisable as the soft-centred lovers of Remember the Night (five stars, check it out). As their near-omniscient shadow, Eddie G. was never better; if the first half is a story about the lust between a man and a woman, the second is a love story between two insurance men. And within each scene, momentum keeps shifting, keeping you constantly disorientated. All that and the atmosphere. The perfect L.A. locations, to augment the studio stuff. The sweat on MacMurray's brow. And Stanwyck extinguishing all the lights, under orders, ahead of the climactic confrontation, like the very spirit of film noir. Debits? I suppose Richard Gaines can't act, the "twisted hopes and crooked dreams" line sounds like placeholder text, and there’s a bit too much score. Hard to give a shit, though, isn't it.
9. The Roaring Twenties (Michael Curtiz, 1939) – A few stray thoughts:
- Is the government warehouse the single greatest set ever constructed? Would love to see the request from Hal Wallis. “A brutalist art deco head fuck, please. Make it far too big on the outside, just unaccountably enormous. A Dali prison, from the afterlife.”
- Don Siegel montages, Gladys George as a lovesick Texas Guinan, Cagney finding such gradations and shadings and complexity in Eddie (his broiling anger engendered by pain), so much deft dialogue in the unapproachable ‘30s style. Glorious.

10. Sunset Blvd. (Billy Wilder, 1950) – “Mabel Normand and John Gilbert must have swum in it, ten-thousand midnights ago.” Sunset Blvd. has a deep creepiness that nothing else has ever quite matched. It’s the flight from poverty into a world of rotting, Gothic glamour; it is rats in the pool, and Wilder’s revulsion at a 50-year-old woman bound for horny gaol; but it is also how inescapable Joe’s fate is, and how utterly we – and Waxman’s score – know it. In its way, it’s the most gruelling of the great films, so bitter and bilious, with the jaundiced shitheel as narrator, and Norma Desmond as spider (the way she pulls Joe in for that New Year’s kiss, fucking yikes): a fundamentally repulsive figure motivated by a deranged sexuality, and a corrosive, wounded vanity. There is pity here too. Yet while the sequence at Paramount – in which she is welcomed by the old-timers, before Wilder’s sick sense of humour kicks in – is so desperately moving, it is also warped by the writer-director’s hysterical ageism. His hero opines, in the shape of a belated olive branch, that there’s nothing wrong with being 50 unless you try to be 25, but what I mostly remember is Wilder getting misty-eyed at the idea of a sweet 17-year-old, and wanting to chuck his guts up at a menopausal woman with a baggy neck. And while there is some balance between the piteous and the monstrous, we land, always, on the latter; the final scene is no less ugly for being obliquely touched by God’s mercy. In it, Wilder breaks the fourth wall to make us all complicit in the raising and forgetting of icons, just as he has somehow twisted a Lubitsch door gag into the bleakest sight on earth (lights going off, through the holes of absent locks, removed because the occupant might otherwise kill herself). No one gets out of Sunset Blvd. whole: not Buster, Anna Q. Nilsson, Norma, Betty or Joe. But oh for those Gillis/Schaefer scenes, and the best insider references in Hollywood history.

***

SEVEN STINKERS*
1. The Chase (Paul Wendkos, 1991) – Feat. the worst soul patch in history. The only film this year that I've watched by accident. Amazon Prime have it listed as The Chase (1994). When Charlie Sheen hadn’t turned up after almost an hour, I became suspicious. Then I turned it off because it is dogshit. Worse even than The Chase (1966).

2. Black Mama, White Mama (Eddie Romero, 1973) – It’s so funny and/or pathetic that MGM doesn’t own any of its pre-1948 catalogue but does own an online casino and *this*. 'Cheers, Louis B. Mayer’s crying x' It’s basically just a soft-core porn film, masquerading as a gender-swap Defiant Ones, filmed haplessly and for almost no money in the Phillippines. Atrocious, sure, but worse than that: just boring - almost impossible to follow, and with no real development in that central relationship. Even its nude scenes aren’t very good, just weirdly infantilising or sadistic. The murder on the bus is so funny. From an original story by Jonathan Demme (see Discoveries, #2)!
3. Secretary (Steven Shainberg, 2002) – I too am clearly interested in masochism, having not switched this shit off after 20 minutes. It is astonishingly bad, despite Spader playing a freak. I’m actually struggling to think of another movie that deals with such complex and important issues in such a glib and superficial and unwarrantedly smug way. Freeway II (see below), perhaps? As a long-recovering self-harmer, Secretary really just made me very angry. The whole thing is so incoherent and unfunny and horribly mannered: a tonal and structural nightmare. Gyllenhaal seems to be playing her character as if she has learning difficulties, which completely undermines everything the script imagines itself to be doing. Two shades of Grey, at most. Zero stars. (Please note that I have further low-key registered my contempt for this film by not bothering to find a hi-res still.)

4. Freeway II: Confessions of a Trickbaby (Matthew Bright, 1999) – A remarkably terrible in-name-only sequel – so bad, in fact, that it makes you wonder if the original was a fluke. It’s loosely based, once more, on a fairy tale (this time Hansel and Gretel), and ultimately tries the same trick – seguing from bad-taste comedy to pathos – but trades for far too long in the former, which here is staggeringly thin and try-hard. From the moment John Landis appears in the first scene as a judge (because, lol, in real life he was contentiously cleared of killing three people), you know that the smugness:actual laughs ratio is going to be off the charts. I could list the other topics it ticks off in its episodic, audience-baiting way, but I’d rather just forget about a film this shit. Natasha Lyonne at least gives it her all as the riot grrrlish heroine, and if you do insist on watching the film, you may as well finish it, since its Taxi Driver-ish denouement is easily the best bit.
5. Species (Roger Donaldson, 1995) – A howlingly awful erotic sci-fi, in which a task force including scientist Ben Kingsley, man of action Michael Madsen and psychic empath Forest Whitaker keep just repeating the same things, while following horny alien psychopath Natasha Henstridge around LA. Each time she kills someone, they turn up shortly afterwards to look at the mess. It feels like a paranoid masculine fantasy about the dangers of casual sex, and so more in tune with the 1950s (or, in another way, the mid-1980s) than the era of the neo-noir. Its events are also in the wrong order, as if designed to offer the least possible emotional or dramatic satisfaction. Whitaker’s character, however, is unwittingly one of the funniest things I have ever seen in a film. H.R. Giger designed the monster, which even by the standards of interactions with HR is grotesque. A baby Michelle Williams, as the earlier of its human incarnations, acts everybody else off the screen; watching Henstridge play the character after that is like bringing off Maradona for Kevin Kilbane.

6. Labyrinth (Jim Henson, 1986) – Is the fuss around this one just a nostalgia thing? It's virtually plotless, and not in a good way. Its overpowering technical elements make it move as slowly as The Lady in the Lake (1944): so much of the film consists of characters just standing around on unconvincing soundstage sets. And it is quite profoundly unfunny, in a fascinatingly specific way, with the greatest incongruous regional Englishness this side of The Empire Strikes Back. What did I like? A few things here and there. The rocks that lined up to look like Bowie. A lovely teddy called Lancelot. The heroic, slow-witted monster, Ludo: undeniably good value. Little minions operating the terrifying death traps (a fun touch). The jump back to the bedroom. And Connelly's, "What have you done?", which has a strange power quite at odds with the rest of the film, and neatly circled back to with that touching apology and instance of forgiveness. I found the rest of it an almighty chore. It's like Return to Oz if it was a bit crap, a feeling that extends even to the ending, which junks a touching, promising melancholy for a party. This period of Bowie's career makes absolutely no sense to me.

7. Don’t Look Up (Adam McKay, 2021) – Not, you would have to say, terribly subtle.

***

SIX RE-APPRAISALS

Because sometimes my opinions are bad.

THREE UP
1. Witness (Peter Weir, 1985) – Is Witness a thriller, an art film, a hands-off romance or a form of cinematic, public-information anthropology? Yes. It is also a masterpiece, and we don’t get too many of those. I last saw the film in my early 20s, at which time I thought it was a solid 4/5. Forgive me. Harrison Ford is the frazzled city cop escorted, by the hand of fate, to an Amish community. That premise is utterly inspired and provides the perfect vehicle for Weir’s obsessions: the collision of modernity and tradition; the intersection of humanity and the natural world. He directs it all so beautifully, with great-use of child’s eye POV, and an effortless sense of command, guiding your thoughts in every shot, whether he’s being direct or allegorical. Best of all is that unforgettable barn-raising sequence, dusted with sweat, sawdust and sexual longing. And did anyone ever pine as poignantly as Kelly McGillis in this picture? The voice, the jutting jaw, the softening smile that communicates across cultures; the endless gazing at Ford through windows. It's one of Ford’s best performances too – if he’s caught pretending now and then, he’s clearly committed to the material, and when it matters, he delivers. His matter-of-fact but choked-up delivery of “If they find me, they find the boy” is just perfection. And the boy? Well he’s even better: little, mouse-like Lukas Haas, adorable in his irregularities, as opposed to Hollywood’s usual idea of a cutesy kid. And little of what’s going on here is recognisably Hollywood. The thriller beats that bookend the picture, perhaps, and a little wish-fulfilment in the ice-cream scene. But it’s kerazy what you could do within mainstream cinema in 1985 compared to now. The backdrop, the quietness, the pauses, the sensuality, the love of nature, the stretches of novelistic character development, the way Weir hops between Fanny and Alexander, Edith Wharton and Dirty Harry. The way you can see, in John Seale’s gorgeous cinematography, what the fuck is going on. A Maurice Jarre score that decides the best way to evoke a community rooted in 19th-century ways is a heap of synths. Just incredible.

2. Jackie Brown (Quentin Tarantino, 1997) – It is, really, just a heist movie with incredible dialogue, and Tarantino – barely believing his luck – truly indulging himself, turning Elmore Leonard into a blaxploitation homage. It’s the opening tune (Womack’s indelible ‘Across 110th Street’), it’s the font, it’s Sid Haig, it’s even the last acting credit done in the genre style: “and CHRIS TUCKER as Beaumont”. It’s the interest in bad smells and the telephone gag lifted from Truck Turner, it’s actual dialogue lifted from Bucktown (“I’m serious as a heart attack”). And it’s Grier, who sang to herself in that movie, and does so here, lip-syncing to perhaps the greatest of all blaxploitation theme songs (only Gaye’s 'Trouble Man' may have the edge). I don’t – and probably never will – understand the argument that this is Tarantino’s best film. Dogs and Pulp still feel revolutionary, and hit me in the heart far earlier. Not for them, either, that weird and dated predilection for Kangol caps. But it was all, still, at this stage, so swaggeringly confident, and so easy. The two sequences of Grier just walking. The first in a side-on travelling shot, before the song swerves into its climactic desperation, and she starts to run. The second, cut to ‘Street Life’. The scene with her in the clothing store: perfect in its pacing, cutting, framing, scoring, circling camera and climactic punchline. So many great lines. At least four massive laughs. De Niro brilliant as a slightly slow thug – still the most underrated thing he’s ever done on screen. It just seems a little light on genuine human feeling, in a way that QT’s first two weren’t... until Forster, his waistband close to his nips, bids goodbye, and walks into the other room.

3. The Dark Knight (Christopher Nolan, 2008) – Pretty good, innit? Particularly in the sweep of Harvey Dent’s story, and in Ledger’s nervy, edgy and exciting performance, which reminds me a little of Dean in East of Eden, trying something every moment even if, sometimes, ironically, that something can be a little the same as the previous thing. Bale sometimes struggles to get any genuine warmth into his performances (there’s just that one scene in Batman Begins where it really comes through, from somewhere), but Caine and Freeman each generate enough for two people in their scenes with him. The beats of the story are just right: it’s so well assembled, so neatly divided between its various elements, with enough surprises up its sleeve, and an antagonist so far ahead of his pursuers that you really start to wonder how they’ll get to him. The answer, it turns out, is sentimental, the sentimentality rather ladled on, and the coda cribbed from Ford’s Fort Apache. It all feels a little forced, and with it a little false, but I’d never champion cynicism over idealism. Other elements, I do find frustrating. Nolan will always prioritise what he thinks of as an arresting image over something that is true to the character (why is the Joker picked up by his fellow bank robbers with his anonymising mask in his hand?); the convoy chase has some nice moments but is really hard to follow spatially; the fight scene at the party looks like it’s from a 1980s TV movie, and the writing still tends towards the overwritten: the Burma story; that awful climactic speech from Oldman, so self-serious that it feels like self-parody. But I liked this so much more than when I first saw it. It’s really entertaining for the most part, has more substance than most superhero flicks, if perhaps less than it imagines, and gets a shot in the arm from Ledger and (particularly in the earlier reels) Eckhart. Also a big fan of Nolan breaking one law of cinematic grammar by shooting Ledger right-side up when he’s dangling upside down from a rope, the kind of, "Fuck it, let's do it" flourish we could use more of in movies.

THREE DOWN
1. Batman Begins (Christopher Nolan, 2005) – “You need to get the love of my life into the alley urgently, before the damage to her mind becomes permanent, let me just fill your entire path with bats.” Batman, there, doing his thing. One of my hotter film takes has long been that Batman Begins is Nolan’s second best film (after The Prestige), whereas The Dark Knight is a bit of a mess. Well, if you thought the Batmobile made a lot of noise, wait until you hear the second screeching U-turn I'm about to make. Bits of this do still work. The scene in the literal bat cave. The old and wondrous device of Bruce having to disgrace himself in the eyes of those he loves in order to protect them. It gives us that beautiful scene at the hotel (“All this, it’s not me. Inside, I am... I am... more”, the emotional heart of these movies), the memorably excruciating birthday party scene, and the eventual reveal (“Bruce?”). His dad is really nicely played. There’s neat mythmaking at times, including that glorious shot of Bats, with wings spread, passing out of the back of the crashing train. And there are a couple of bits irresistible to a British viewer: a band of marauding cons led by the singer of James (!), and the way Oldman says “sorry” while driving, inescapably the behaviour of an English person. Look at the rest of it, though. It toys with iconography in that self-satisfied, very noughties way; the dialogue is alternately portentous and smugly glib; the action is really not great (shout-out to that terrible car chase); Neeson’s climactic speech goes on for fucking ever, and though the Scarecrow is a lot of fun, the principal villainy is really weak. The whole subplot of Bruce training with the vigilante monk-ninjas just seems so laughable and of its time. And I’m not sure the final act makes any sense at all. How weak, exactly, is this emitter? All in all, a pretty humiliating climbdown from Yours Truly. And did you see how I’ve reappraised The Dark Knight?

2. 辣手神探) (John Woo, 1992) aka Hard Boiled – “You’re a woeful undercover cop.” “There’s no good or bad, just personal style.” A near-mythic John Woo actioner, now back in circulation. In perfect late-capitalist style, it had ended up being owned by a construction company who refused to license it – before being finally rescued by Shout! Factory, and shared with Tubi and Criterion. Woo is, of course, more interested in destruction. The film can’t perhaps match its reputation – inevitably burnished by becoming almost impossible to see – but its fagpacket plot, music-video visuals and elements of uninteresting villainy are offset by spectacular flashes of action, which include Chow firing away while (a) sliding down a banister, (b) whooshing out of a slot in a morgue, (c) holding a baby. Some of the stuntwork is just incredible, and if you found, say, The Raid or Dredd irresistible rather than repetitive, this is going to knock your brain out of your open mouth. The film’s attendant weirdness, and passages of monotony, were largely down to its troubled production. Woo’s initial concept was for a gritty, demystifying policier about detectives pursuing a baby poisoner. But after that story upset everyone who read it, and his regular screenwriter suddenly died (not poisoned), he served up, partly off-the-cuff, a live action cartoon that features Bond-ish villains hiding arms in a hospital, one of the Tony Leungs playing an off-the-chain undercover cop, and the director himself dispensing wisdom as a sagacious former policeman who appears to live in a jazz club. If the moral grubbiness of going undercover is evoked, there is little revisionism applied to Chow’s character, a one-man army who still finds time to put cotton wool in babies’ ears during a siege. Woo’s tongue-in-cheek approach extends to neat in-jokes at either end of the film, which begins in a bird-café, with none of his trademark doves in sight. When you’re wondering, near the movie’s close, just when they might turn up, his camera lingers for a moment on a poster of a dove on a hospital wall, its message of peace counterpointing the utter mayhem exploding around it. Hard Boiled isn't as good as I remembered, which of course is a little disappointing, but it's still essential for anyone halfway interested in action cinema.

3. The Mad Miss Manton (Leigh Jason, 1938) – Barbara Stanwyck Nose Appreciation Club, sign in here. The Mad Miss Manton Appreciation Club, I'm afraid I've resigned. This one’s simply not the best use of Missy’s talents: playing the kind of dizzy debutante role you associate with Constance Bennett or Carole Lombard. In those moments where she and Fonda play it straight and soppy, it’s beautiful, but there's not nearly enough of that. The film is a curious confection made at RKO, and while both leads were unusual in the ‘30s in effectively freelancing across the different studios, it still feels weird to find them at this end of Gower Street, since Stanwyck had such a Paramount feel, and Fonda was pure Fox, the place where he eventually signed. Gotta love those insane RKO sets, though: did a cityscape and subway ever look more sanitised? What makes this all even odder, though (if you’re a massive fucking nerd), is that the script is by Philip Epstein, who spent almost his whole life at Warner, almost always working with his brother (they wrote large chunks of Casablanca). His script is, surprisingly, absolutely all over the fucking place, its central murder mystery being both hopelessly simplistic and unbelievably convoluted – the exact opposite of what it should be. Stanwyck’s ditzy sidekicks, meanwhile, are simply too trivial – one-dimensional characters whose decisions never seem real – and the film features an awful lot of people just screaming and shouting. I’ve always loved Sam Levene, and he’s quite funny in this when he’s not overdoing it, but that isn’t much of the time; ‘mugging’ barely does the rest justice. Thank goodness for the leads, then. Stanwyck, even miscast and at about half-power, has these moments that melt you, and that irradiating talent that has always rendered someone irresistible (also: that nose, man). Fonda didn’t like playing daft comedy, and rarely got a dafter part than this one, but did the doe-eyed dolt as well as anyone. Incidentally, Miss Manton’s lawyer here is called Hopsy, which perhaps gave Sturges the idea for The Lady Eve, the last and best of the stars’ three teamings. This one isn’t in the same league, even the same universe, with its choppy editing, slapdash use of stock footage (at one point mirrored, so all the shop frontages read backwards) and general noisy incompetence, but there are a finite number of pre-’45 Stanwyck films, and I do love them all in some way.

***

FIVE OBSESSIONS
1. John Ford. Always and forever my favourite director. His films bypass my critical faculties altogether, and hit me in the soul. I explained a little about it in this piece for the Guardian. I watched 14 of his films this year, four of them new to me (including Bucking Broadway, Hell Bent and Two Rode Together). Highlights, as well as those above, included a revelatory rewatch of 3 Godfathers, and Sergeant Rutledge on the big screen (with Swedish subtitles, as that was the only print the BFI could get at short notice).

2. Stanwyck. The greatest screen actor ever to walk the earth (Gish second, Cagney third, thanks for playing). I'm on 75 films now, so just seven to go. Then I imagine we go round again. This year's six new watches were close to the dregs, but she's very good in her first major role, trapped behind The Locked Door.

3. Blaxploitation. It was March, I had OG flu, and once I’d got past the not-being-able-to-do-anything stage, all that seemed to help was pimps being roundhouse-kicked in the head. Coffy, Foxy Brown, Across 110th Street, Friday Foster, Truck Turner, Bucktown... It was quite a week, you cracker-ass mutha.

4. Denzel Washington. On the film-logging website, Letterboxd, users can see which actors they have watched the most since joining. The only actor in my top 40 who is in colour is Denzel Washington. Do I understand why he has now taken to essentially playing Jason Statham across the three increasingly silly films in the Equalizer franchise? No, I do not. But as long as he’s happy. I love that guy.

5. Margaret Sullavan. I have been bewitched: it was the voice that did it. I dove deep on Sullavan while researching my Blu-ray essay on Little Man, What Now? last year, and have kept diving. Back Street and Next Time We Love didn’t quite come off, but in The Shopworn Angel (see Discoveries, #23), she is little short of astonishing. She made 16 films. I have seen 11, and I’m coming for the rest.

***

FOOTNOTE:
*'stinker' is a word I got from the great forgotten comedy of the 1940s, I Love You Again.

***

Thanks for reading

Tuesday, 24 December 2019

Review of 2019: Part 3 – Movies

Part 1 was about books, Part 2 was live stuff. This one's about films. I only saw 95 this year, which by my previous standards is pathetic, but is also probably Healthy and A Good Thing.

Fourteen premieres of the year...

... being old films I saw for the first time in 2019, and really liked.



1-3. Three Colours Red (Krzysztof Kieślowski, 1994), The Double Life of Véronique (Kieślowski, 1991) and No End (Krzysztof Kieslowski, 1985) – The climax to Kieslowski’s tricolore trilogy is a sort of twisted Amèlie: a wilfully dark slow-burner that dares you to love it. Part-time model Irène Jacob has a sexist boyfriend, a junkie brother, and has just run over a dog. That dog belongs to reclusive retired judge Jean-Louis Trintignant, who hates everyone and is spying crustily on his neighbours. After that charming meet cute they begin a tentative friendship, but this is no simple Hollywood heartwarmer and Trintignant no thawing grandpa: he remains a complex character, and their relationship is as much about honesty as redemption. If it speaks to you, though – and it does to me – you’ll never forget it. This is Kieslowski’s most stylish film: playful at times, almost hallucinatory at others, with Felliniesque tendencies and an inspired use of music. Those flourishes augment a story that feels minor and even disjointed for quite a while – but stick with it. The final 20 is astonishing.

When I was watching movies, this was the year of Kieslowski. Véronique is an understated, hypnotic Kieslowski film that runs the gamut from eerie to joyous, but thrums with quiet pain, while radiating artistry in the imagery, music (by Zbigniew Preisner) and performance. Jacob is chokingly effective as Véronique and Weronika, sensitive, identical women who never meet, but feel an intangible connection. It’s often plotless – and its bits of plot can feel like contrived whimsy – but it’s mesmerising too, and when it hits, it hits hard. You may know it’s coming, when Véronique takes a closer look at those transparencies... oof. I’d like to watch this again soon, as I’m not quite sure how to judge it: the moments of profound visual and emotional beauty (Jacob walking in the light between shadows) vs some apparent shortcomings that are more prosaic. It could end up being a favourite.

And then there was No End, which began the whole thing. That's a mesmerising Kieslowski film about a ghost, a grieving widow and a political trial. It's a sad, wise, wintry work, profound about loss and revealing about communist Poland. Every scene is brilliant.

I'm going to watch Dekalog for the first time in 2020. I can't wait.



4. Heat Lightning (Mervyn LeRoy, 1934) – Like The Petrified Forest but fun: a tough, crackling, slangy piece of Pre-Code magic about mannish mechanic Aline MacMahon, her frustrated kid sister (Ann Dvorak) and the fugitives, floozies and other lost souls who stumble into their desert gas station. It’s a little masterpiece: a film that juggles irreverence, suspense and drama, working hard for its emotional moments, which are understated and all the more effective for it. And it has pretty much my dream cast, dominated by MacMahon – who’s in terrific form – but with a decent part for Dvorak (largely sidelined by Warner’s after taking an eight-month honeymoon and briefing against the studio from the boat), as well as perfect supporting bits for Willard Robertson as McMahon’s quietly-spoken admirer, Glenda Farrell as a flirtatious divorcee, and Frank McHugh as her put-upon chauffeur. Plus Lyle Talbot as a nervy bank robber on the lam. It is 1933 after all.

5. The Twilight Samurai (Yōji Yamada, 2002) – A wonderful film about widowed, low-ranking samurai Hiroyuki Sanada trying to care for two daughters – and a mum with dementia – as honour and clan loyalties threaten to draw him into conflict. It’s a mixture of the conventional and the markedly not: there’s a little spoonfeeding and a mawkish coda, but also a hero who’s told off for being smelly, and a bit where the long-promised face-off is delayed by the villain wanting a chat and eating his own cremated daughter. In either mode, the film has a lovely feel to it: touching, melancholic but good-humoured, ultimately elegiac, and while the accent is rarely on action, it can do that too. Sanada is perfect as the taciturn hero: reluctant retainer and doting father, spurning the love of his life through a sense of duty.



6. Tales of Manhattan (Julien Duvivier, 1942) – The best pormanteau film I’ve seen from Hollywood’s Golden Age, beginning with Charles Boyer, Rita Hayworth and Thomas Mitchell trapped in a warped, noirish love triangle, and ending with Paul Robeson arms outstretched, in full voice – the stories all linked by the same increasingly bedraggled tailcoat. There’s a phenomenal collection of talent assembled here by Fox, both behind and in front of the camera, including director Julien Duvivier (Pépé Le Moko), writers Ben Hecht and Lamar Trotti, and one of the best casts brought together in this or any other era. And though the film juggles genres, it brings the same heightened sensibility to each, as well as ruminating gamely on the nature of luck. With the exception of a tiresome chapter starring W. C. Fields – excised from the original release, restored on home video – every single one of these stories is good (the African-American one is compassionate and treats its younger characters quite well, though it’s also patronising and stereotypical to the point of racism), and two of them are exceptional.

The pick of the bunch is a screwball masterpiece in miniature, utilising Ginger Rogers’ gift for instant emotional connection and Henry Fonda’s ever underrated comic timing in a funny, lushly romantic story about a bride falling in love with her best man. And in the other stand-out, which features a lovely part for veteran character actor Harry Davenport, homeless alcoholic Edward G. Robinson gets cleaned up, in more ways than one, to attend a university reunion, which – naturally thanks to George Sanders – turns into a referendum on his character. Right from the ingenious play-within-a-film near its commencement, you know this movie’s going to be something special, and it is. There’s wit and wisdom to spare. There’s also Charles Laughton as a frustrated composer, J. Carrol Naish as an armed robber and Robeson in dungarees, married to Ethel Waters, spouting socialist agitprop – so something for everyone, really. Also, did I mention how good Thomas Mitchell is here? He is. And he’s fantastically directed.



7. The Warriors (Walter Hill, 1979) – Eight gang members in lovely leather waistcoats try to fight their way home to Coney Island from The Bronx, pursued by the cops and every ridiculously-attired badass in town. A richly visual cult action film from Walter Hall, with echoes of early John Carpenter, tons of suspense and a gloriously grimy NY milieu. On one level it’s completely preposterous (one rival gang appear to be Kiss wearing baseball gear, another are in dungarees and on rollerskates), but luckily it’s also amazing: one of the great all-in-one-night movies (see also: After Hours, Die Hard, American Graffiti, Attack the Block). And, apparently oblivious to it, and in other ways rather unreconstructed, it’s also really quite gay. It can add something curious and intangible to a B-movie when you get wooden actors speaking stylised dialogue, but when those bad actors go big, it falls down. That’s the case here: keeping it simple, the Warriors work – even if a few could be written more fully – while hamming baddie David Patrick Kelly is notably A Bit Much. Cracking film, though.



8. They Came to a City (Basil Dearden, 1945) – A genuinely inspiring socialist allegory, based on a J. B. Priestley play, with a heady atmosphere of victory-scented utopianism that places it unmistakably in 1944. A bit heavy-handed in places, but thoroughly striking, with rich rhetoric, a notably fine Googie Withers performance, and modernist, abstract sets that are almost as fascinating as her face.

9. Nine Queens (Fabián Bielinsky, 2000) – A terrific, endlessly surprising Argentine film about two con men walking the streets of Buenos Aires, trying to close the deal of a lifetime. Affecting and amusing, with a cast of memorable characters – particularly Ricardo Darin’s goateed, merciless Marcos.



10. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (Peter Ramsey, Bob Persichetti and Rodney Rothman, 2018) – When a film has a cartoon Peter Porker pig known as Spider-Ham and that cartoon Peter Porker pig says something so unexpectedly moving that it nearly makes you cry – that’s when you know you’re watching a good film. It’s that heart that sets it apart, though it is also very funny and well-animated, and Lord and Miller’s post-modernism freshens the formula without overwhelming the story. Even the action climax doesn’t overstay its welcome (much). Film noir isn’t from the 1930s, though. Sort it out.

11. Lenny (Bob Fosse, 1974) – An exceptional, intelligent Lenny Bruce biopic, with Dustin Hoffman’s acerbic, neurotic, obsessive, impulsive Bruce – an insecure adulterer and hopeless morphine addict, as well as trailblazer and mirror to America’s rampant hypocrisy – a little more recognisable than the Manic Pixie Dream Lenny of The Marvellous Mrs Maisel. It’s directed in incomparable New Hollywood style by Fosse, a clear influence on films from Raging Bull to Jackie, with credible performances led by Hoffman’s pyrotechnics, though Bruce’s professional life is rather more interesting to watch than his personal one, meaning that the decision to angle the story on his relationship with his wife (Valerie Perrine) isn’t necessarily right.



12. Harper (Jack Smight, 1966) – A genuinely special PI film that bridges the gap between The Big Sleep (with Bacall in the General Sternwood role) and Altman’s Long Goodbye, as Paul Newman’s tough-talking, hungover Lew Harper scoops old coffee grains out of the bin for re-use – and gets outsmarted a half-dozen times, while rarely losing his smirk. At times the plot plods and the story feels secondhand, the film touched too by those naff ‘60s elements that never feel authentic, but it’s packed full of scintillating William Goldman dialogue, with a first-rate cast – including Shelley Winters as an alcoholic former starlet, Julie Harris a smack addict chanteuse, and Arthur Hill as Newman’s best bud – and imaginative imagery from Conrad Hall. The final scene in particular is an absolute classic: Goldman at his zenith, and Newman close to his; a shame then that the writer’s conspicuous contempt for women, fat people and “faggots” serves elsewhere to detract from the sardonic lyricism of his lines.

13. Crumb (Terry Zwigoff, 1995) – A revealing, difficult documentary about counter-culture cartoonist Robert Crumb, mental illness and America. The sequence in which you see his brother's comic books degenerate from charming pastiches of popular art into endlessly and impossibly dense word-heavy blue scrawls is as harrowing a depiction of insanity as I've seen. I've found it hard to get it out of my head.



14. The Adventures of Mark Twain (Irving Rapper, 1944) – Wonderful episodic Americana about steamboat captain, gold prospector and comedy roaster Sam Clemens (Fredric March) – better known by his nom de plume. March is excellent, sidestepping his penchant to play too big, and there are lovely moments throughout – particularly the love scene in the rain, and the characters tumbling from the Huck Finn manuscript – though the second half is sometimes too conventional, and Alexis Smith (as Mrs Clemens) is increasingly asked to eulogise Twain’s greatness for the benefit of the viewer, rather than enjoy a character of her own. Still, the writers’ knowledge of Twain is clearly first-rate (I’m talking the works, not the events), and they do a good job of knitting his observations and witticisms into the script without it ever feeling mannered or laborious. Plenty of his gags still hold up, though the ones in his climactic speaking tour are admittedly absolutely terrible bantz. Max Steiner’s score has his usual virtues and vices: lovely themes alongside clichéd jingles and hysterical cues.

***

Old favourites

The ten best films I rewatched:



1. The Magnificent Ambersons (Orson Welles, 1942) – Fragments of genius. Amidst the wreckage are five or six of the most stunning passages in American cinema. I wrote at length about the film here.

2. Ghost World (Terry Zwigoff, 2001) – You can take your Juno, your Scott Pilgrim, even your Heathers, and chuck them in a skip, because Ghost World just does it all so much better. Well, all of it that's worth doing. I'm beginning to think this melancholy, bitingly hilarious crystallisation of teen ennui might be the only film I'll ever really need.



3. Holiday (George Cukor, 1938) – Unfortunately I am in love with Katharine Hepburn in this film. And in love with the Potters. Lew Ayres starts as a cartoon, then adds layer upon layer. Inspired, inspiring, intoxicating. It’s pretty much perfection. Here's a full-length piece about it. The film is out on Criterion Blu-ray, including the original 1930 version as an extra, next month.



4. On the Waterfront (Elia Kazan, 1954) – Along with Star Wars and Les 400 Coups, this was the movie that got me into movies. I had that amazing Italian poster on my wall as a teenager. I’ve been to a concert because they were performing a bit of the score. I still know the (incomparable) taxicab scene off by heart. The film, enduringly problematically, is an apologia for informing, in which director Elia Kazan and screenwriter Budd Schulberg shamefully equate the parlour communists they ratted out to the HUAC with murderous mobsters. Context and subtext aside, though, it remains an absolutely exhilarating piece of cinema: powerful, rousing, moving – even sexy.

Brando, in the greatest of all his performances, is Terry Malloy, the uneducated ‘bum’ who threw his one shot at a title fight and is now the mascot of a corrupt waterfront labour union run by Johnny Friendly (Lee J. Cobb). After setting up a talkative neighbour to get shoved off a building, Terry falls for the victim’s sister, convent girl Edie (Eva Marie Saint), and feels the first painful stirrings of conscience. There’s such an intensity and a depth to Brando’s performance here, which conjures beauty and nobility and even innocence from a character who is thick and crude and inarticulate and sometimes ugly. Something is always happening beneath the surface of his skin, and the details too are dynamic: the way he picks up Saint’s glove, cleans it off, then puts it on, as he sits on a swing and continues his guileless, pained, teasing courtship.

Schulberg’s dialogue is lyrical but real, the location photography groundbreakingly good, and Leonard Bernstein’s sole movie score a revelation, while Kazan dips into horror iconography and avant garde camera swishes – the latter simulating Terry’s punchdrunk climactic stagger – to augment the action. It comes too with career-best turns from Saint (her debut), Cobb and Karl Malden, as well as the finest thing Steiger did outside of The Pawnbroker. I still find it a troubling, difficult and mendacious film, but it also gave me the gift of cinema and I will always love it.



5. Top Hat (Mark Sandrich, 1935) – Not the most groundbreaking, challenging, interesting, avant garde or seamless musical, but hands-down my favourite. The five numbers are transformative, transcendent, even transfiguring, and around them is a slick, funny Wodehousian comedy of mistaken identity, only occasionally made mystifying by time, and played to the hilt by a perfect supporting cast: bask in Helen Broderick’s one-liners, Edward Everett Horton’s double-takes and that weird, slightly saucy pouty thing that Eric Blore keeps doing.

I really love Ginger’s facial acting in this, especially the two greatest of the dance sequences: ‘Isn’t This a Lovely Day (To Be Caught in the Rain)’ and ‘Cheek to Cheek’ – the latter a heightened, aching, impossibly beautiful five minutes of cinema, and irresistible shorthand for the intoxicating nature of Depression-era escapism, utilised in films like The Purple Rose of Cairo and The English Patient.

There are some wonderful flashes of instant mythmaking too, particularly Sandrich’s exuberant shot of Fred and Ginger’s feet travelling to the dancefloor at the start of ‘The Piccolino’, and the delirious, ecstatic way they twirl out of frame at the close, love conquering all, including the elaborately drawn-out plot whose very superficiality enhances those peaks of exotic American romanticism.



6. A Star Is Born (George Cukor, 1954) – An utterly devastating musical melodrama, with Judy’s best performance, some brilliantly perverse numbers, those delicate, beautifully balanced CinemaScope visuals from Cukor, Leavitt and Hoyningen-Heuse, and Moss Hart’s rich, economical dialogue. It can feel jumpy at times – and not just because of the two lost passages (now partially reconstructed) – with long scenes, sudden epiphanies and then leaps forward, but the classic sequences are legion. Three favourites are the early passage in Norman’s bedroom – which brilliantly foreshadows and elucidates in a handful of images and lines – Esther’s emotionally complex monologue in her dressing room (followed by a ‘show must goes on’ musical reprise), and Maine putting on one last great performance prior to his fateful dip.

The last hits very close to home for me and as such is virtually unwatchable. That Esther-Norman relationship is one of the most effective and believable I’ve seen on screen: so tactile and true, with a rhapsodic tenderness, an easy, playful chemistry and a shared pain that you engage with almost physically. Mason’s acting in the night court, and later in his bed, is mesmerising. And then there’s ‘The Man That Got Away’ – arguably the outstanding musical sequence in all of cinema, though the journey there was tortuous. Cukor and co were on at least their fourth vastly different conception of the scene by the time they cracked it. It’s absolute magic: the only thing more extraordinary than what Judy is doing with her body – contorting in communion with her muse in that dim, smoke-filled dive – is what she’s doing with her voice.

If you love the film as I do, and enjoy reading, I’d really recommend Ronald Haver’s book about A Star Is Born and its 1983 reconstruction, a mixture of making-of (and unmaking-of, and remaking-of), Hollywood history, detective story and love story.



7. Unforgiven (Clint Eastwood, 1992) – A shortsighted gunfighter, a hero who can’t get on his horse, and a bloke being shot on the shitter. Yes, it’s the last great Western: Eastwood’s ambivalent masterpiece about the cost of killing, and a lot else besides. It’s classic in style but offbeat in nature, chock-full of stylised, lyrical language (which extends even to the opening crawl) and powered by an astonishing ensemble. English Bob’s unmasking, Clint’s heart-to-heart with the damaged damsel, and the Schofield Kid’s tear-flecked confession are all extraordinary highlights. Saul Rubinek? Saul Rubbernecking, more like. *high five* There's a long(-ish) read here.

8. Inside Llewyn Davis (Joel and Ethan Coen, 2013) – The Coen brothers film that I really love: yearning, folk music, wintry sadness, counter-intuitive plotting and cats. Call me conventional but I could live without the John Goodman passage. The musical scenes are utterly perfect.



9. I Love You Again (W. S. Van Dyke II, 1940) – An immaculate, unheralded comic masterpiece, with Bill Powell’s effortless tour-de-force as teetotal pillar of the community Larry “Grape Juice” Wilson, who gets a whack on the head and reverts to his old self – charming conman, George Carey. He heads home to raid the savings, only to fall in love with his own wife (Myrna Loy, naturally), who’s busy divorcing him. Frank McHugh is hilarious as the phony medic along for the ride. Ingenious script by Charles Lederer, Harry Kurnitz and George Oppenheimer, whose hand seems most apparent. There’s the odd rough edge from Woody Van Dyke’s obsessive, breakneck one-take approach, but he certainly knew how to film comedy, especially with a script and cast as good as this one.

10. Double Indemnity (Billy Wilder, 1944) – “Yes, I killed him. I killed him for money and for a woman. I didn't get the money and I didn't get the woman. Pretty, isn't it?” A near-perfect noir, with poetic insurance salesman Walter Neff (Fred MacMurray) suckered into a murder plot by housewife, anklet wearer and angel of death, Phyllis Dietrichson (Barbara Stanwyck). It’s cleverly plotted, intensely suspenseful and full of the most extraordinary dialogue and voiceover, written by Wilder and Raymond Chandler.

Stanwyck is good and MacMurray terrific – cast brilliantly against type for the first time – though no-one can touch Edward G. Robinson as the gruff, adoring, fast-talking investigator from up the corridor, who smells a rat but can’t ever quite believe that it’s his friend. Their doomed bromance gives the film its heart and its deeply moving final exchange – another of Wilder’s impeccable pay-offs, though only because the gas chamber finale that he shot was rejected by censors. I’m even coming around to Stanwyck’s wig.

***

And here's a top 25 of the decade...

... boiled down from a long list of 70 to a shortlist of 68, then a final 25. It's favourites, really, not best, though that distinction is always a little muddy. The top two are right, anyway; the rest of it is up for grabs.



25. Bad Lucky Goat (Samir Oliveros, 2017)
24. Silver Linings Playbook (David O. Russell, 2012)
23. Boyhood (Richard Linklater, 2014)
22. Paperman (John Kahrs, 2011)
21. Skeletons (Nick Whitfield, 2010)
20. I Am Not Your Negro (Raoul Peck, 2016)
19. The Other Guys (Adam McKay, 2010)
18. The Interrupters (Steve James, 2011)
17. The Intouchables (Olivier Nakache and Éric Toledano, 2011)
16. Nanny McPhee and the Big Bang (Susanna White, 2010)
15. A Fantastic Woman (Sebastián Lelio, 2017)
14. The Descendants (Alexander Payne, 2011)
13. Attack the Block (Joe Cornish, 2011)
12. Frances Ha (Noah Baumbach, 2012)
11. Best of Enemies (Robert Gordon and Morgan Neville, 2015)



10. Certain Women (Kelly Reichardt, 2016) – Kelly Reichardt has such a unique way of looking at the world, at humanity, and this triptych of short stories is an instant classic: a rich, tactile, beautifully-edited film that's brilliantly low key in its performances, its humour and its sumptuous, washed-out, finely-grained cinematography. First-watch review here.

9. Amy (Asif Kapadia, 2015) is a tough watch, but it feels essential, not just for its vivid picture of a fascinating, deeply troubled young woman, but also for its wider significance: as a plea for people to stop being so horribly selfish, to stop seeing excess and illness as ‘rock and roll’ and drug abuse as a joke, and for the media to realise that if it wants to paint itself as a crusading Fifth Estate, then some basic humanity wouldn’t go amiss. First-watch review.



8. The Kid with a Bike (Jean-Pierre Dardenne and Luc Dardenne, 2011) has elements of fatalism without being pessimistic, tells a simple story that never looks for an easy way out, and eschews sentimentality while radiating a bold and uncompromising sense of humanity. It moved me very deeply. Full review.

7. Margaret (Kenneth Lonergan, 2011) – A breathtaking, one-of-a-kind character study about a high-school student (Anna Paquin) wrestling harrowingly with life's vicissitudes after causing a fatal accident. It's profound, rounded, literate, poetic and intimate, full of completely surprising and real characters and developments, and climaxing with a scene of remarkable catharsis in lieu of any easy answers. More here.



6. Moonlight (Barry Jenkins, 2016) – An intensely beautiful, compassionate film in three parts about a quiet, 'soft' African-American boy being battered by the inner-city experience as he tries to deal with his tortured sexual awakening. First-watch review here.

5. Pride (Matthew Warchus, 2014) takes a premise that seems merely like a liberal wet dream and fashions an astonishingly erudite, funny and intensely moving movie, which works as an examination of our shared humanity, a startling recreation of the last stand of our country's working class, and a much-needed rallying cry at a time when the left has never seemed weaker or more irrelevant. Full review here.



4. Mad Max: Fury Road (George Miller, 2015) – An exhilarating feminist actioner that unleashes torrents of water on the risible '80s Mad Max films from an improbably great height. More here.

3. Inside Llewyn Davis (Joel and Ethan Coen, 2013) – This sad, whimsical and purposefully baggy story of missed opportunities and shambling urban alienation is an extraordinarily special piece of work, and one which avoids cliché not because it thinks it’s clever to do so, but because this is how things would be, how the characters would behave. Full first-watch review here.



2. Beasts of the Southern Wild (Benh Zeitlin, 2012) is remarkable in every way: stunning to look at, full of jaw-droppingly lyrical dialogue and blessed with a triumphant, eminently hummable Cajun soundtrack. Lit by a multitude of brilliant sequences that seem to come out of nowhere, but don't, and dominated by Wallis's heroics (including some excellent screaming), it packs an emotional punch like nothing else I've seen in years. More here.



1. Winter's Bone (Debra Granik, 2011) – Debra Granik's feminist masterwork is the key film of the decade so far: an unorthodox, spine-tingling thriller, a humanist fable, and a staggering study of a good person under almost intolerable pressure. In her breakout role, Jennifer Lawrence is Ree Dolly, a strong, selfless, smart-mouthed 17-year-old living with her vacant mother and two young siblings in Missouri's Ozark Mountains. Once it ran with bootleg moonshine, now this here's Meth Country, and if her crystal-cooking father doesn't turn up for his court hearing, they're going to lose the house, the woods and the whole family unit. So Ree sets out in search of him, facing threats, silence and regular beatings from pinch-faced people who share a lot of the same blood that runs in her veins, and down her face. There's brutality and violence to spare, but it's the humanity you remember. Full review.

***

Thanks for reading, and thanks in particular to those who've shared these pieces.